Inspiration

I get my posts removed on Reddit all the time. Usually the only explanation is something like "Rule 4" and I have no idea what I actually did wrong. One day I thought, what if that was the game? You get removed, you try to figure out why, and eventually you get it. That became Removed.

What it does

Every day there is a new made-up subreddit, like r/HorizontalCats or r/SoupTheory. It has five rules in its sidebar, and one of them is blacked out. That hidden rule is the puzzle.

You build post titles from a bank of 14 words and submit them. If your post is approved, nothing happens. If it gets removed, you get a strike. Three strikes and you're banned for the day. By comparing what got through and what didn't, you start to see the pattern. Sometimes the rule is about meaning (every post needs an animal), sometimes about letters (no letter E), sometimes about length (each word longer than the last).

When you think you know the rule, you apply for mod. You get five reported posts and swipe left to remove or right to approve. Get through without three strikes and you're modded. At the end you get a modmail letter that reveals the rule, along with your stats and streak.

If you're stuck, you can ask a mod once a day. It costs you one post, and the mod tells you what kind of rule it is.

After you finish, you can see what everyone else posted that day and which titles survived, plus a small board of the players who got modded in the fewest moves. Everyone gets the same rule on the same day, so the comments become a place to compare theories. The game also works in eight languages: English, Spanish, Portuguese, French, German, Italian, Dutch and Turkish. Each language has its own word bank but the same daily rule.

A new case is posted automatically every day.

How we built it

It's built with Devvit Web, using React, Tailwind and Vite on the client and Hono on the server. The secret rule is only known to the server, so every post and every exam answer is checked there. Redis stores player progress, daily stats, streaks, the shared list of posted titles and the leaderboard.

Each day's subreddit, rule, word bank and exam are generated from the date, so every player gets the same puzzle. The word banks are tuned so that about half of random titles pass, which keeps the game fair without being obvious. A scheduled job creates the new daily post just after midnight UTC.

For the look, I went with a moderator's desk at night: dark wood, a warm lamp, cream paper case files, rubber stamps and brass seals. The sounds (stamp, paper, gavel) are generated in the browser, and they can be muted.

Challenges we ran into

Supporting eight languages was harder than expected. Italian has almost no words ending in S, so one of the rules had no possible answers until I added more Italian words. The word "at" means "ate" in Dutch and "horse" in Turkish, so every word had to be tagged per language. Letter rules also had to ignore accents.

Balancing difficulty took a lot of tweaking. Too many approved posts and the rule is meaningless, too few and players get banned before they learn anything.

The removal message also needed care. My first version showed a fake reason like "Read the sidebar", and when I tested it, it confused people. They thought it was a real instruction. Now the rule is simply blacked out and the removal just says which rule number you broke.

Accomplishments that we're proud of

I'm happy that it has its own look and doesn't feel like a template. I also like that it's genuinely shared: the same puzzle for everyone, in eight languages, and after playing you can see how everyone else approached it. Small details like the gavel when you get a strike and the stamp appearing as you swipe make it fun to play.

What we learned

In a deduction game, feedback is everything. Players need to clearly see what changed between a post that passed and one that didn't. I also learned that on Reddit the post in the feed is the real front door, so that card deserves as much attention as the game itself.

What's next for Removed.

I want to add harder weekend cases that combine two rules, let the community submit their own subreddit names and rules, and add user flair for streaks and mod rank.

Built With

Share this project:

Updates

Submission history