Inspiration
The Makeshift Project makes YT videos around a simple concept: rank the following without knowing what comes next. Their videos were genuinely entertaining. I couldn't stop thinking about ways to turn it into some sort of game. My first thought was a web-based game. But, it didn't quite feel right due to the heavy reliance on the social aspect of the game. When I found the Reddit Developer program, it felt like the right fit. Reddit is already a place where people argue about rankings constantly, why not make a game out of it.
What it does
A fellow Redditor ranks a list, their honest answer, with the whole thing laid out in front of them. Then it gets scrambled and dealt to you one item at a time. You place each one blind. No peeking ahead, no undo, you commit and you move on.
At the end you find out how close you landed to their ranking, you earn a label somewhere between The Kindred and The Wildcard, and the good part you see where everyone else landed too. Turns out misery loves company, and so does being confidently wrong about where "pineapple" goes. Then you can remix any ordeal or pose your own.
How I built it
It's a Devvit Web app, React 19 + Vite + Hono + Redis, built with Claude Code. The inline splash view deals you the first item immediately, no tutorial. Heavy screens load in the expanded view.
Under the hood: each post's deal order is seeded deterministically per-post so every player worldwide gets the identical sequence. Scoring uses Kendall tau distance against the creator's ranking. Consensus is a live Borda count (context only) separate from your label. Every post auto-themes itself by extracting the dominant color from its cover image. There's a built-in browse catalog (Hot / New, category filter), push notifications when takers weigh in, and a shuffle mechanic so creators can randomize deal order to raise the difficulty.
Challenges I ran into
I framed the whole game wrong for almost a week. I kept describing it as "the creator predicts how the crowd will rank it," and built an entire creator dashboard around "how well did you read the room." It never felt quite right and I couldn't put my finger on it. There was no single breakthrough that got me to this point, I just did a lot of trial and error testing to find out what felt right and what felt wrong. Eventually, I settled on the whole creator-taker relationship as a challenge that the creator issues, not a mind-reading contest. The second I stopped trying to think of creators as Jigsaw (from Saw), every screen got simpler.
Navigating the Devvit ecosystem was a bit of a challenge for me. Claude Code helped me move fast through it, reading and reasoning over the API and schema directly so I could stay focused on building rather than context-switching into docs.
Reddit won't load random images. Their content security policy blocks arbitrary image URLs, so everything gets re-hosted to Reddit's CDN. Fun bug: pasting an image link fired two uploads of the same URL, Reddit rejected one as a duplicate, and whichever lost the race showed a fake "couldn't load this image" error. Fixed with an in-flight lock that survives re-renders.
What's next for Ordeal
I'd like to implement some sort of dashboard or leaderboard for creators. They'd be able to track all of their ordeals in one place, and see how well each one's doing by looking at post statistics. I also think it would be fun to possible implement slightly different variations of the ranking concept, where creators would have different game modes to choose from.
Built With
- claude
- devvit
- hono
- react
- redis
- typescript
- vite
