Inspiration

Donut Drop is a match-3 game that puts you in a donut factory where the conveyor belts have gone haywire. Rather than donuts coming from the top and filling the map downward, they can follow snaking paths through the map. The game introduces mechanics like switches that change conveyor direction, plain donut disposal, jellied conveyors that cause donuts to get stuck and coffee that needs to be cleared. These introduce new opportunities for strategy to meet opportunity in the match-3 genre.

I thought up and prototyped a very simple version of the game in September of 2016. At that time, I was too busy to finish it, so the prototype sat on a shelf. When the Meta VR Glasses were announced, I thought that the device needed 3d, stereoscopic, head tracked, hands-first games that could be played casually while doing other things. That is a perfect fit for Donut Drop. When the Meta VR Start competition opened, it was time to build.

The reason I am putting this in the "Adapted or Significantly Updated" submission division instead of "New" is because the concept predates the beginning of this contest. That said, this game submission was built from scratch for this contest.

What it does

Donut Drop is a chaotic match-3 game that has you collecting donuts as they come racing down winding conveyor belts every which way. It is up to you to move donuts to adjacent conveyors by hand as you create matches of 3 or more. The game comes with 25 starter levels, including 7 tutorial levels. Experience coffee, jelly, plain donut disposal, switches and special donut combos (stars, stripes and rainbows).

Donut Drop has unique gameplay mechanics, but it also has a unique delivery. Donut Drop is played in the Horizon OS multi-tasking environment, but not as a typical 2d panel app. Immediately upon launching the game, you will see the game has head tracked stereoscopic depth. It is a match-3 game meant to be played in VR: move your head around to see the tiles under the donuts. Reach out with your hands to move the donuts.

Many of the level maps are not flat; they have a visually interesting topography. Clearing donuts has them flying off the conveyor. Completing a level results in an explosion of donuts. Touches like these were key to delivering immersive yet casual gameplay while also allowing a Meta VR Glasses user to multi-task.

Donut Drop was developed for hands, not controllers and buttons. Reach out and move a donut by hand. Make a match and watch the donuts go flying. The game can be played entirely seated in a small space - like an airplane seat. The game maintains its aspect ratio, but can be resized and moved wherever the player wants it. That means you can play on a small tray table, or on a giant movie screen.

How we built it

Donut Drop was built for the Meta Quest 3 as a 3d stereo panel app. It includes head tracking code to provide real immersive 6DOF depth. This depth is not just a gimmick; it is core to the gameplay. For instance, being able to see if a Jellied conveyor is 1, 2 or 3 layers deep can help you know where to focus your attention early in a level.

The levels for Donut Drop were hand made with a custom level editor. Our editor gives us the ability to define the map size, shape, conveyor flow, initialization states, completion goals and tutorial/story messaging.

Challenges we ran into

Our biggest challenges were introducing depth and touch consistently and comfortably in a Horizon OS panel. Some examples:

  1. We initially had a donut move flow that was something like "first touch donut A, next touch donut B, then donuts swap". This worked functionally, but was tedious and not intuitive. Dragging had to be supported. So, we tried "touch, drag, release". This was kind of janky too. Eventually, we arrived at what we have now: drag to the nearest cardinal edge, once you reach the tipping point, the swap happens. It is easy, fast and feels fluid. What you might not notice is the smoothed attachment to the dominant cardinal direction, the slight "lifting" of the selected donut or the mirror movement of the adjacent donut.
  2. We initially wanted to have even more depth, but there are limits to what is comfortable with depth. The original design was going to introduce conveyors with depths -3, -2, -1, 0, +1, +2, +3. However, anything sticking out of the screen meant you had to put your hand through a donut to achieve a "touch". This led us to 3 depths: 0, -1 and -2. Still visually interesting, but the conveyors are always at a depth that feels great for touch.
  3. Level difficulty was a challenge as well. We did three things to address level difficulty. First, we removed hard move caps from the initial 25 levels. These will appear in later levels, but as a player is learning the ropes, they should not be punished with a level failed screen. Second, we adjusted the structure of some levels to make them a tad easier. These changes were a direct result of intense play testing. Thirdly, we adjusted the 2 and 3 star requirements. This resulted from a mixture of human play testing and automated play testing. The automated play testing allowed us to determine likelihood of certain conditions occurring and set the 2 and 3 star requirements based on actual achievability.

Accomplishments that we're proud of

We are proud to deliver a fun casual matching game that you can play while multi-tasking on a Quest 3 or the future Meta VR Glasses with no controllers needed. We love that we were able to deliver a spatial App that runs alongside other Meta apps. We are also proud of the tutorial system. It wasn't listed in the challenges, but it was super important that onboarding was easy and we think we delivered on that.

What we learned

Balanced level design is not easy. Since we plan to release many future level packs, it is good to learn this lesson early. Depth and hands don't "just work". You need to design for them.

What's next for Donut Drop

  1. An official release to the Meta store.
  2. Eye tracking. While the documentation from Meta suggests this should work with panel apps, it does not work currently. We wanted to release Donut Drop with an eye tracking mode, but we had to abandon this since it doesn't work in panel apps at the moment. The fact the documentation exists suggests the feature is coming. As soon as it does, we will add support for it.
  3. Level packs. We want to introduce a level pack (3 or 4 bakers' dozens) that players can buy to continue the adventure.
  4. More gameplay mechanics. Level 25 is insanely fun. It is built by mixing the switch mechanic with the plain donut disposal mechanic. We want to add some more mechanics that create similar synergies.
  5. Theme packs. These could provide holiday or brand themed donuts, music, etc.

Built With

Share this project:

Updates

Submission history